Guide

Paper punch card or digital stamp card?

A paper punch card is cheap and simple, and it is enough for some shops. A digital stamp card costs a little setup but cannot be lost, cannot be stamped by a borrowed ink stamp, and shows you who comes back. Which one fits depends on what you want to learn from your regulars.

A sample digital stamp card. The cafe name is made up.

The short answer

If you only want a simple thank-you for regulars and you do not mind never knowing who they are, paper works. If you want customers to keep the card, want to stop fake stamps, or want to reach regulars who stopped coming, a digital card does what paper cannot.

Side by side

Paper punch cardDigital stamp card
SetupPrint cards and buy a stampCreate the card online and print one QR poster
Running costReprinting cardsA free plan, or a monthly or yearly plan as you grow
Lost cardsCommon; the stamps are goneThe balance is kept in your account, not on the card
Fake or extra stampsEasy with a similar stampA unique code per customer and an optional wait between two stamps
Who your regulars areUnknownNames, visits and rewards in your dashboard
Reaching customersNot possibleOffers and reminders on the wallet card
What the customer carriesOne more cardNothing new: the card is in their phone wallet

When paper is enough

Paper is a fair choice if you have a handful of regulars you already know by name, you have no plans to contact them, and the cost of a free item now and then does not worry you. It is also the simplest option for a pop-up or a one-off event.

The trouble starts when the shop grows. More staff means more stamps nobody can check, and more customers means more cards left in old jackets.

What a digital card adds

  • The card stays in the phone wallet next to the customer’s other cards, so it is there at every visit.
  • Each stamp is scanned, so you can see who stamped what and when, and set rules such as a minimum bill.
  • You see your members, the stamps given and the rewards handed over, and your most frequent customers by name.
  • You can send an offer or reminder to the card, which paper can never do.
  • You can change the reward later, and the change reaches every card.

Switching without losing your regulars

Customers with half-full paper cards are your best customers, so honor their stamps. A simple way: when a regular brings a paper card, they join the digital card at the counter, and your staff add the same number of stamps with Saniye Assistant. Keep accepting paper cards for a few weeks, then stop printing new ones.

Put the join poster where people wait, tell regulars once at the counter, and the switch takes care of itself. The step-by-step guide covers the setup, or you can create your card now.

Questions

Is paper cheaper?

At the start, usually yes. A digital card on Saniye can start on the free plan with the stamp card, and paid plans add more card types, customers and staff. Compare plans for your country on the pricing page.

Can customers move their paper stamps to the digital card?

Yes, in practice: the customer joins, and your staff add the stamps from the paper card with Saniye Assistant. You decide the rule, and you can stop accepting paper whenever you choose.

What about customers without a smartphone?

A digital card needs a phone that can scan a QR code. For the few who have none, you can keep a paper card going during the switch.

Do customers need to download an app?

No. They scan the code, type a name and phone number, and the card is added to Apple Wallet or Google Wallet. It also opens in the phone browser.

Create your card today

The stamp card is free. No credit card needed, and your customers need no app.